35 Common Lean Six Sigma Project Errors: Discussed for Each DMAIC Phase

Common Lean Six Sigma project errors are often overlooked. Lean Six Sigma is a methodology businesses use to improve their processes by reducing defects, minimizing waste, and improving quality. The methodology uses the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) framework. However, there are common errors that businesses make in each of these phases that can impact the project’s success. By avoiding these errors, companies can increase their chances of success in their Lean Six Sigma projects. This article delves into the most common mistakes experienced by the author for each DMAIC phase.

Lean Six Sigma Project Errors in the DEFINE Phase

The Define phase of a Lean Six Sigma project is the first and critical phase in the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) methodology. It sets the stage for the rest of the project, and errors made during this phase can significantly impact its success. Some common mistakes in the Define phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include:

1. Lack of Clarity in the Problem Statement

One of the most common errors in the Define phase is a lack of clarity in the problem statement. The problem statement should clearly define the problem, its impact on the business, and the desired outcome. Without a clear definition of the problem, it can be challenging to identify the root cause and develop an effective solution.

2. Failure to Define the Scope

Another common error in the Define phase is a failure to define the project’s scope. The scope should define the project’s boundaries, including the processes, departments, and people involved. Projects that are too broad can be overwhelming and challenging to manage, while projects that are too narrow may not address the root cause of the problem.

3. Inadequate Stakeholder Involvement

Stakeholder involvement is essential in the Define phase to ensure the project’s goals align with the organization’s objectives. Stakeholders should be involved in the problem statement, scope definition, and project planning to ensure that their perspectives are considered. The lack of stakeholder involvement can lead to a lack of buy-in and support, which can hinder the project’s progress.

4. Insufficient Data Collection

Data collection is critical in the Define phase to identify the problem’s scope and impact on the business. The data collected should be relevant, accurate, and sufficient to support the problem statement. Insufficient data can lead to incorrect assumptions, inaccurate problem identification, and ineffective solutions.

5. Poorly Defined Metrics

The Define phase should also define the metrics that will be used to measure the project’s success. Metrics should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. Poorly defined metrics can lead to ineffective solutions and an inability to measure the project’s impact on the business.

6. Rushing Through the Define Phase

Another common error in the Define phase is rushing through it to get to the “real work.” Taking the time to define the problem and scope, involve stakeholders, collect data, and define metrics can significantly impact the project’s success. Running through the Define phase can lead to ineffective solutions, as the project’s goals and scope may not be clearly defined.

7. Lack of Leadership Support

Leadership support is essential for the success of a Lean Six Sigma project. Without leadership support, the project may lack the necessary resources, funding, and buy-in from stakeholders. Leadership should be involved in the Define phase to ensure that the project’s goals align with the organization’s objectives and that the project is given the necessary resources to succeed.

In summary, some common errors in the Define phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include a lack of clarity in the problem statement, failure to define the scope, inadequate stakeholder involvement, insufficient data collection, poorly defined metrics, rushing through the Define phase, and lack of leadership support. Avoiding these errors and ensuring a robust Define phase can set the stage for the rest of the DMAIC methodology and increase the project’s chances of success.

Lean Six Sigma Project Errors in the Measure Phase

The Measure phase of a Lean Six Sigma project is the second phase in the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) methodology. This phase involves collecting data on the process or problem to establish a baseline and quantify the issue’s magnitude. Some common errors in the Measure phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include:

1. Inadequate Sample Size

One of the most common errors in the Measure phase is using an inadequate sample size. Insufficient sample size can lead to inaccurate data, making it difficult to establish a baseline and identify the root cause of the problem. A sample size that is too small can also lead to incorrect conclusions and ineffective solutions.

2. Poor Data Collection Methods

Another common error in the Measure phase is using poor data collection methods. Poor data collection methods can lead to inaccurate data, making it challenging to identify the root cause of the problem. Data collection methods should be well-designed, standardized, and followed consistently.

3. Incorrect Measurement Tools

The tools used should be appropriate for the collected data and provide accurate measurements. The measurement tools used should also be calibrated and verified for accuracy. Using incorrect measurement tools can also lead to errors in the Measure phase.

4. Failure to Validate Data

Validation of data is critical in the Measure phase. Validation helps ensure that the data collected is accurate and error-free. Failure to validate data can lead to incorrect conclusions, ineffective solutions, and an inability to measure the project’s impact on the business.

5. Poor Data Management

Data management is also critical in the Measure phase. Data should be stored securely, and access should be controlled to ensure only authorized personnel can view and manipulate the data. Poor data management can lead to lost data, corruption, and an inability to access data when needed.

6. Inadequate Analysis

Inadequate analysis is another common error in the Measure phase. Data analysis should be conducted thoroughly and appropriately to identify trends and patterns in the data. Inadequate analysis can lead to incorrect conclusions and ineffective solutions.

7. Overreliance on Software

While software can be a valuable tool in the Measure phase, overreliance on software can lead to errors. Software should be used to support the data collection and analysis process, but it should not replace human judgment and decision-making. Overreliance on software can lead to incorrect conclusions and ineffective solutions.

In summary, some common errors in the Measure phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include using inadequate sample size, poor data collection methods, incorrect measurement tools, failure to validate data, poor data management, inadequate analysis, and overreliance on software. Avoiding these errors and ensuring a robust Measure phase can lead to more accurate data, which can help identify the root cause of the problem and increase the project’s chances of success.

Lean Six Sigma Project Errors in the ANALYSE Phase

The Analyze phase of a Lean Six Sigma project is the third phase in the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) methodology. In this phase, the team analyzes the data collected in the Measure phase to identify the root cause of the problem. Some common errors in the Analyze phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include:

1. Rushing Through the Data Analysis Process

One common error in the Analyze phase is rushing through the data analysis. Data analysis is critical in the Lean Six Sigma process and should be conducted thoroughly and systematically. Running through the analysis process can lead to errors and incorrect conclusions.

2. Focusing on Symptoms Rather Than Root Causes

Another common error in the Analyze phase is focusing on symptoms rather than root causes. The team may be tempted to address the symptoms of the problem rather than identifying and addressing the root cause. This can lead to ineffective solutions that do not solve the underlying problem.

3. Ignoring Relevant Data

Ignoring relevant data is another common error in the Analyze phase. The team may overlook data critical to identifying the root cause of the problem. Ignoring relevant data can lead to incorrect conclusions and ineffective solutions.

4. Failure to Verify Assumptions

Assumptions can impact the analysis of data and the conclusions drawn from it. Failing to verify assumptions can lead to incorrect conclusions and ineffective solutions. It is essential to verify all assumptions to ensure the analysis is accurate.

5. Lack of Collaboration

The Analyze phase involves team members collaborating to identify the problem’s root cause. It is essential to have a collaborative approach to ensure that all team members contribute their expertise. Lack of collaboration can lead to missed opportunities and a failure to identify the root cause of the problem.

6. Overcomplicating the Analysis

Overcomplicating the analysis is another common error in the Analyze phase. The team may use complex analysis methods that are unnecessary or inappropriate for the data. Overcomplicating the analysis can lead to errors and incorrect conclusions.

7. Failure to Prioritize Causes

Once the root cause of the problem has been identified, it is crucial to prioritize the causes based on their impact on the process. Failure to prioritize causes can lead to ineffective solutions that do not address the most significant causes of the problem.

In summary, some common errors in the Analyze phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include rushing through the data analysis process, focusing on symptoms rather than root causes, ignoring relevant data, failing to verify assumptions, lack of collaboration, overcomplicating the analysis, and failure to prioritize causes. By avoiding these errors, the team can ensure that the analysis is accurate and the root cause of the problem is identified, leading to effective solutions.

Lean Six Sigma Project Errors in the IMPROVE Phase

The Improve phase is the fourth step in the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) methodology in Lean Six Sigma projects. During this phase, the team uses the insights gained from the previous phases to develop and implement solutions to improve the process. Common errors in the Improve phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include:

1. Jumping to Solutions

One common error in the Improve phase is jumping to solutions without thoroughly analyzing the data and root causes identified in the Analyze phase. This can lead to ineffective solutions that do not address the underlying problem.

2. Insufficiently Testing Solutions

Before implementing a solution, it should be thoroughly tested to ensure it is effective and does not cause unintended consequences. A common error in the Improve phase is insufficient testing solutions, leading to ineffective solutions or even further problems.

3. Failing to Involve Key Stakeholders

Involving key stakeholders in developing and implementing solutions ensures their success. A common error in the Improve phase is failing to involve critical stakeholders in the process, resulting in resistance to the solutions and their ultimate failure.

4. Overlooking Simple Solutions

Sometimes, simple solutions can be the most effective in improving a process. However, a common error in the Improve phase is overlooking simple solutions instead of more complex or flashy solutions.

5. Lack of Standardization

Inconsistent implementation of solutions can lead to variability in the process, ultimately resulting in further problems. A common error in the Improve phase is failing to establish standardized processes and procedures for implementing solutions.

6. Failure to Document Changes

Documenting changes is important for tracking progress and ensuring that the solutions are implemented consistently. A common error in the Improve phase is failing to document changes, which can result in confusion and lack of accountability.

7. Resistance to Change

Resistance to change can occur at any stage of the Lean Six Sigma process, but it is particularly prevalent in the Improve phase when solutions are being implemented. A common error is failing to address resistance to change, which can fail the solutions.

In summary, common errors in the Improve phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include jumping to solutions without thorough analysis, insufficiently testing solutions, failing to involve key stakeholders, overlooking simple solutions, lack of standardization, failure to document changes, and resistance to change. By avoiding these errors, the team can ensure that solutions are effective and have a lasting impact on the process.

Lean Six Sigma Project Errors in the CONTROL Phase

The Control phase is the final step in the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) methodology in Lean Six Sigma projects. The goal of this phase is to ensure that the improved process is sustained over time. Common errors in the Control phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include:

1. Lack of Ownership

A common error in the Control phase is failing to assign ownership of the process to a specific individual or team. Ensuring that improvements are sustained over time can be difficult without clear ownership.

2. Inadequate Training

Training is essential to ensure that all employees involved in the process understand the changes and can effectively implement them. A common error in the Control phase is inadequate training, which can result in confusion and inconsistent implementation.

3. Failure to Monitor the Process

Monitoring the process is critical to ensure improvements are sustained over time. A common error in the Control phase is failing to monitor the process, which can result in a relapse into old habits and the re-emergence of problems.

4. Lack of Communication

Effective communication is important to ensure everyone involved knows the changes and their role in sustaining them. A common error in the Control phase is failing to communicate effectively, leading to confusion and resistance to the changes.

5. Failure to Update Procedures

Procedures and standard work instructions should be updated to reflect the changes made in the Improve phase. A common error in the Control phase is failing to update procedures, leading to confusion and inconsistency in the process.

6. Lack of Data Tracking

Data tracking is vital to monitor the effectiveness of the improvements over time. A common error in the Control phase is failing to track data, which can result in a lack of visibility into the process and the effectiveness of the improvements.

7. Neglecting to Address feedback

Feedback from stakeholders, including employees and customers, is important to identify areas for further improvements. A common error in the Control phase is neglecting to address feedback, which can result in missed opportunities for further improvement.

In summary, common errors in the Control phase of a Lean Six Sigma project include lack of ownership, inadequate training, failure to monitor the process, lack of communication, failure to update procedures, lack of data tracking, and neglect to address feedback. By avoiding these errors, the team can ensure that the improvements made in the Improve phase are sustained over time and that the process continues to improve.

Read this article for more about Lean Six Sigma success factors at the implementation or project levels.

If you like what you read in this article
and require assitance using these concepts and tools in you business,

simply drop us a note with your contact details and we’ll get right back to you.

Keep up to date by following us on LinkedIn


Latest Articles

Take a look at the wealth of information we regularly post on our Articles page.

Process Excellence is a vast subject, and our site is filled with valuable information. Use the ‘search‘ function at the top of the page to find a specific topic for you.